I'm satisfied with the perm ileo. The bag has been very manageable for me.
Before my surgery, I researched the J pouch procedure extensively including this forum and read about
complications, issues and successes. I just wanted to be out of pain, which is why I was strongly leaning toward perm ileo. I then discussed the possibilities with my gastro and surgeon, and they both told me that they weren't recommending the J pouch procedure any more because of complications, and because folks did so well with the bag. I'm just so happy to not be in pain anymore and thinking about
where the nearest toilet is at all times!