Mia,
I started SCD to manage my spinal arthritis more than my UC actually. My UC is mild to moderate and mostly in remission, but I was told that the arthritis could be a sign of poorly controlled UC, so I thought I'd see if diet could help (I also really wanted to avoid biologics, whether that's sensible or not). I can definitively say that diet certainly helps, but isn't a panacea. I'd say diet plus the supplements I take help reduce pain and stiffness by about
60-85% depending on how strict I am. The few times I've totally cheated on the diet I've had a debilitating flair of the arthritis (and a worsening of digestive issues).
Lately, the mix that seems to work is SCD plus the homemade yogurt, coconut kefir, curcumin and wild oregano oil. Frankly, when I regularly take wild oregano oil (which is effective at killing gram negative bacteria) I can even deviate from the SCD a little bit, making me think my big problem isn't just leaky gut but is an immune response to the dysbiosis associated with UC. I'm sort of anxious about
regularly taking oregano oil as I wonder what beneficial bacteria it might also be killing, so I tend to save it for after a restaurant meal where I'm not sure I was as strict as possible.
I'd say it can't hurt to try diet modifications and see whether they help. You can try a strict elimination diet (start with just chicken and carrots for a few days and then slowly add things in) or you can try paleo, GAPS, SCD, etc. Phoenix Helix does a handy summary of the various diets recommended for auto-immune disorders.
I'd also add that I think there's a weird aspect of the online world of people who advocate diet to control AI diseases, which can give you the impression that if diet isn't helping you, you're not being strict enough or you need to stop eating seeds, or some other failing on your part. That's clearly not the case. Diet doesn't work for everyone, so if it seems like it isn't helping, it probably isn't.
AS is a major challenge and the truth is you have to pick your balance of risks, and the risks of meds compared to the risk of poorly managed AS might be the only choice you have. Give diet a try, but if it isn't working, there are other options that might seem less worrying once you know you've exhausted all other options.
Post Edited (FSLondon) : 4/24/2017 6:28:50 AM (GMT-6)